Rotten tree!

Last month in an article at the Hill, The Supreme crisis of Chief Justice John Roberts, Jonathan Turley mentioned that a recent poll found that less than half of Americans have a favorable view of the United States Supreme Court. That's largely due to the overturning of Roe v. Wade. But we the people have even lower approval ratings for Congress which is part of the Legislative branch, at only 18%, and the media is only trusted by 32% of people, Turley reported. 

As for police, who are part of the executive branch, their approval rating is about the same as that of the justices, only about half. In U.S. Confidence in Institutions Mostly Flat, but Police Up, by Megan Brenan at Gallup:

Faith in the police fell in 2020 to 48% after George Floyd was murdered while in police custody. After increasing to 51% in 2021, confidence in the police dropped again in 2022 and dipped further last year, to a record low of 43%.

Can we agree that the tree is rotten and we need to plant a new one? 

The uneducation of America! Supreme Court at Lewiston High School

Don't expect a decision anytime soon about the intertidial land controversy which the Maine Supreme Court heard today. Intertidal is the word used to describe the land between the low and high tide marks. Here's a Maine Public story by Kaitlyn Budion, at Maine Public: Moody Beach dispute reaches Maine Supreme Court.  The justices will probably take forever because they have to first determine if Peter Masucci et al. (and others) have standing because according to the story he's "asking the court to overturn a 1989 decision which says that private land ownership extends to the low tide mark." 

Apparently, the signs that were put up are offending people. Here's a story by AnneMarie Hilton, at the Morning Star, with photos of the signs. From Maine's highest court hears arguments for public access to intertidal land case: 

If the court clarified that intertidal land is not an easement, but rather subject to the public trust doctrine — which preserves certain natural resources for public use — Parker said they could expand the definition of “fishing, fowling and navigation” without overturning the 1989 ruling. 

That's how this issue could be resolved, according to a Maine assistant attorney general, Lauren Parker. The decision in 1989 was by the Maine Supreme Court. I don't know if the court has ever overturned one of their own decisions...that is admitted it made a mistake.    

At schools throughout Maine this week the Maine Supreme Court justices are hearing the cases so students can watch. I wanted to attend the event, but couldn't; the public wasn't invited! Upon arriving, I was asked my name by a woman with a list. I wasn't on it, so I couldn't sit and watch. What? I didn't have any weapons on me. There seemed to be enough space on the bleachers, though I don't know how many students were going to be attending. Nobody seemed to know that. A man who must have been with the justices and the court said it was not their policy. "An email went out to parents and others," I was told at the main office where I went to ask what the situation was.  

Funny thing is they want to show the students what the Maine Supreme Court justices do...but they're teaching students about a system which is failing! One of the most obvious failures is that justice is not swift; and that's one of the reasons our ancesters separated from Massachusetts 100 years ago! It was taking too long for people here to have their cases heard because of the distance from the court. 

A paragraph from my letter to Maine Policy Institute

I just added a tab for Maine Policy Institute to the top of my page. This morning, I wrote to them using their online form and saved it in Google Documents before sending it. Here's one paragraph from it.

I will not appear on October 7, 2024 to the scheduled arraignment in Fort Kent. I refuse to accept the jurisdiction of a court that is part of a failed system - a system that has failed to provide effective counsel to my son in nearly two years, and to other individuals it is constitutionally required to appoint counsel to. At attorney rates of $300 per hour in the private sector, the state can't compete and can neither afford to pay $150 per hour to provide counsel under the current definition of "counsel".

Off duty officer in New York - lawsuit filed in road rage incident

The officer was apparently intoxicated when he crashed into cars and shot a man in the head on June 6, 2024. Here is a bit from the Associated Press story by Karen Mathews on October 2, 2024:  

According to the lawsuit, Tran’s alcoholism and mental health problems were known to his police superiors and should have disqualified him from serving as an armed officer, but he was nonetheless carrying a department-issued 9mm pistol that he used to shoot Patel.

Lewiston Mass shooter's medical records might be accessed through probate court

The following story explains Woman who lost husband and son uses probate process to obtain gunman's records: 

A judge on Tuesday granted Cynthia Young’s petition to become a special administrator of Robert Card’s estate so she can have legal authority to obtain the records for herself, others who lost loved ones, and attorneys preparing lawsuits. The move was not opposed by Card’s son, who is his sole heir.

If the paperwork was filed in Hancock County, there'd be no other judge to preside over the case other than Judge Blaisdell. From High court suspends Hancock County probate judge "It’s not clear yet when the four-month suspension period for Hancock County’s only probate judge will commence," and regarding Judge William Blaisdell IV: 

He told the justices that he let his personal life interfere with his duty to the court and had let his mental health deteriorate and had become overwhelmed by the number of cases he was handling